Escalator Malfunctions: Close Calls and Injuries Amidst Crowds

From Kuala Lumpur malls to American ballparks, escalating incidents of malfunction raise urgent questions about safety and oversight.

Published July 01, 2024 - 00:07am

4 minutes read
United States,337,x0,y120&format=pjpg&width=1200

Image recovered from

In recent months, escalator malfunctions in different parts of the world have highlighted a growing concern regarding public safety and the maintenance of these critical infrastructure elements. An alarming incident unfolded in the bustling Mid Valley Megamall in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, when the top step of an escalator detached completely causing panic among shoppers. The malfunction left parts of the escalator protruding and paralyzed users with fear. Describing her ordeal, one shopper recounted hearing a loud noise before witnessing parts of the escalator ahead pop out. She and other shoppers immediately ran back to safety; luckily, no one was hurt.

The danger posed by malfunctioning escalators isn't isolated. Stateside, a more severe incident occurred at American Family Field in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Following a Brewers game, an escalator malfunctioned, rapidly increasing in downward speed and leading to 11 injuries. Milwaukee Fire Chief Aaron Lipski mentioned that such emergencies were unprecedented at the ballpark. Witnesses, like Greg Braggs Jr., a producer for a Chicago sports media outlet, vividly described the chaos: 'Then a second later, it just broke loose. Now you're rolling down this thing... it started picking up serious speed.' Unlike the incident in Kuala Lumpur, this malfunction resulted in tangible injuries, with some fans being taken to the hospital and others treated on-site.

Braggs' account adds a human dimension to what statistics might overlook. He described an older woman being among those hit by the falling wave of people at the escalator's bottom, underscoring the unpredictability and heightened risks in such incidents. Despite the traumatic experience, Braggs reflected on his gratitude that the injuries weren't more severe. Kaylee Klein, another witness, echoed similar sentiments, describing how fans were 'plummeting down' as the escalator gained speed.

While the causes of these malfunctions remain under investigation, immediate conjectures tie them to either maintenance issues, aging equipment, or simply being overwhelmed by large crowds. The Brewers' escalator incident occurred despite regular post-game staffing to manage the flow of spectators. This reality raises questions about the robustness of existing safety measures and protocols, particularly in venues that host massive crowds regularly.

The concerns are far from new. Historical precedents, such as the out-of-control escalator in Rome back in 2018 that injured at least 20 people, show a recurring pattern that necessitates intervention. Technology, design, and management practices for escalators must evolve to mitigate these risks. Currently, escalator safety regulations differ globally, and inconsistencies can lead to preventable accidents. The events in Kuala Lumpur and Milwaukee serve as potent reminders that systemic overhauls may be required to ensure safety uniformly. Even when scrutinized under a local lens, these incidents reveal gaps in oversight that need urgent addressing.

Operators of facilities with high foot traffic can take proactive measures to assess the integrity of their equipment periodically. For instance, the Mid Valley Megamall had recently faced a significant safety concern in May, when a fire broke out due to overheating oil, forcing a temporary shutdown. The mall's management needs to reassess fire safety and escalate measures to include stringent checks on escalator maintenance.

Interestingly, in Milwaukee, Gov. Tony Evers had signed a bill providing over $500 million in public funding for stadium improvements over the next 27 years. As part of these renovations, escalator safety may gain additional funds for upgrades and maintenance. This step is essential not only for enhancing public safety but also for restoring consumer confidence. When the public feels secure in public spaces, it reflects positively on the institutions responsible for those spaces.

The escalation incidents should prompt a broader, in-depth conversation about safety standards, maintenance protocols, and rapid response mechanisms. It is critical for public and private sectors to collaborate on ensuring stringent safety measures are framed and actively implemented. For shoppers and fans alike, assurances of their safety should not be passive promises but verifiable actions. Hopefully, moving forward, these discussions will lead to concrete steps and frameworks to prevent and effectively manage escalator malfunctions across the globe.


How would you rate this article?

What to read next...