Supreme Court to Decide on Controversial Transgender Care Bans
The U.S. Supreme Court's upcoming term will tackle significant questions about the legality of bans on transgender healthcare for minors.
Published June 24, 2024 - 19:06pm

Image recovered from washingtonexaminer.com
The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a pivotal case challenging the constitutionality of state laws restricting transgender medical treatments for minors. This marks the first time the high court will address the legality of such bans, which have been enacted by more than 20 states across the country.
The case in question involves a Tennessee law that restricts the use of puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and gender-transition surgeries for minors. The law has faced significant resistance from various quarters, including the Biden administration, which contends that these bans violate the U.S. Constitution's 14th Amendment guarantees of equal protection and due process.
Supporters of the Tennessee law argue that these treatments are experimental and could be harmful to the young patients involved. Lawmakers in Republican-led states, where similar legislation has been enacted, claim that these measures protect children from undergoing irreversible procedures that they might later regret. Tennessee's law allows for lawsuits against healthcare providers who violate its terms, and such providers could also face professional disciplinary actions.
Opponents, including medical associations and families of transgender children, argue that gender-affirming care can be life-saving and is essential for the well-being of transgender youth. They emphasize that gender dysphoria—a condition marked by significant distress due to a discrepancy between one's gender identity and assigned sex at birth—is associated with higher rates of suicide. Gender-affirming care, they argue, has shown effectiveness and can significantly improve the happiness and well-being of transgender minors.
Several plaintiffs, including three transgender teenagers and their parents, have sued Tennessee to defend their right to access these treatments. The Biden administration has intervened in the lawsuit, aligning itself with the plaintiffs. A federal judge initially blocked the Tennessee law in 2023, stating that it likely violated the 14th Amendment. However, the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals later reversed this decision, allowing the law to take effect.
The Supreme Court's decision to hear this case has far-reaching implications. If the court rules in favor of Tennessee, it could embolden other states to pass similar legislation. Conversely, a ruling that strikes down the Tennessee law could invalidate similar bans across the country. This case, United States vs. Skrmetti, will be argued in the Supreme Court's upcoming term starting in October.
It's important to note that this case is part of a broader legislative effort by Republican-led states to limit the rights of transgender individuals. These efforts include bans on transgender participation in sports, restrictions on bathroom usage, and limitations on discussions of gender identity in schools. On the other side, Democratic-led states and the federal government have been working to extend protections for transgender individuals, including new federal regulations aimed at safeguarding transgender students.
Historically, the Supreme Court has taken up several cases involving LGBT rights over the past decade. In 2015, the court legalized same-sex marriage nationwide. More recently, in 2020, it ruled that a landmark civil rights law protects gay and transgender employees from workplace discrimination. However, the court has also issued rulings that favor religious objections to providing services for same-sex weddings, highlighting the contentious nature of this cultural battle.
The court's upcoming decision on this issue will likely have a monumental impact on the legal landscape surrounding transgender rights in the United States. Both sides of the debate are preparing for a hard-fought battle, with significant implications for the inclusivity and protection of transgender individuals in American society.