Sanders Criticizes Harris: Does Parenthood Define Humility?

Sarah Huckabee Sanders drew ire with her remarks about Kamala Harris' lack of biological children. The controversy sheds light on broader societal attitudes towards womanhood and leadership.

Published September 19, 2024 - 00:09am

4 minutes read
United States
https://www.gannett-cdn.com/authoring/authoring-images/2024/09/18/USAT/75270636007-xxx-091724-dfp-trump-flint-rg-45.JPG?auto=webp&crop=4717,2654,x0,y491&format=pjpg&width=1200

Image recovered from freep.com

At a recent rally in Flint, Michigan, Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders made a controversial remark that has ignited discussions about womanhood, leadership and parenting. Speaking to a crowd of supporters of former President Donald Trump, Sanders, in her opening remarks, criticized Vice President Kamala Harris for not having biological children.

Sanders spoke fondly of her own experiences as a mother, sharing an anecdote about her daughter, which concluded with the statement, 'My kids keep me humble. Unfortunately, Kamala Harris doesn't have anything keeping her humble.' This remark has led to widespread condemnation from various quarters, with critics arguing that Sanders' comments are not just inappropriate but also indicative of a deeper bias against women who do not adhere to traditional family structures.

Reacting to Sanders' comment, co-host Mika Brzezinski of MSNBC's Morning Joe questioned the Trump campaign's obsession with women who do not have children of their own. This sentiment echoes broader social criticisms regarding the role of women in society and the value placed on motherhood.

It is not the first time such views have been aired by Trump's allies. U.S. Sen. JD Vance of Ohio made similar comments in 2021, decrying the influence of what he termed 'childless cat ladies' over the country. Vance included Harris among those he criticized, despite the fact that Harris is a stepmother to her husband Doug Emhoff's two children.

Kerstin Emhoff, Doug Emhoff's ex-wife, took to social media to defend Harris. She stated that Harris has spent her career working for all families, which keeps her humble. This defense was echoed by several other public figures and commentators, including pop star Taylor Swift, who voiced support for Harris, referring to herself as a 'Childless Cat Lady' to call out the derogatory nature of such comments.

Critics have pointed out the irony in Sanders, a political figure born into privilege, questioning Harris' humility. Harris, the daughter of immigrants, has often been characterized as someone who has worked hard to achieve her current status. The contention raises questions about what qualities are deemed necessary for political leadership and how gendered perceptions of family and humility play into these expectations.

Sanders' own political record has also come under scrutiny. As White House Press Secretary, she defended the Trump administration's policy of separating families at the border. Critics argue that Sanders' comments about family values ring hollow given her support for policies that detrimentally affected children and families.

This incident is part of a larger pattern of attacks on female politicians that target their family lives and personal choices. Right-wing commentators like Laura Loomer have used inflammatory language to question Harris' suitability for leadership based on her childlessness. Loomer's remarks highlight the ugly side of political discourse that seeks to demean women based on their reproductive choices.

The persistent focus on Harris' lack of biological children has also been seen by some as part of a broader strategy by Trump's campaign. By continuing to bring up divisive and inflammatory issues, the campaign may be seeking to solidify its base, even if it means alienating undecided voters or moderates.

Polls suggest that women voters have increasingly shifted away from Trump, pointing to a potential miscalculation in targeting Harris in such a manner. Political analysts such as Kristen Soltis Anderson have noted that attacks like these could backfire, alienating the very demographic that Sanders and Trump need to win over.

As the election approaches, the discourse around women in leadership and their personal lives is likely to intensify. This incident serves as a reminder of the challenges female leaders face and the societal expectations they must navigate. The debate over whether parenting, particularly biological parenting, should be a criterion for political effectiveness and humility continues to provoke strong reactions on both sides of the political spectrum.

Ultimately, this controversy over Sanders' remarks underscores the persistent scrutiny faced by women in politics. As society grapples with evolving definitions of family and leadership, the conversations sparked by such incidents will contribute to a broader understanding of what it means to lead and serve, beyond traditional roles and expectations.

Sources

How would you rate this article?

What to read next...